Sunday, April 20, 2008

Carter's folly

It is getting more and more difficult to give Jimmy Carter a pass on his foolishness.

He wrote a book on the Israeli vs. Palestinian conflict in 2006 called Peace, Not Apartheid, not so subtly linking the debate on Palestinian statehood in the Middle East to the repression of blacks for decades by a wealthy white minority in South Africa. He has also shown extremely poor judgment when paying calls on certain dictators; Oliver North reports here that he once clinked glasses with Fidel Castro, which indeed did occur in May of 2002. Read about that here.

But now, laying a wreath at the grave of Yasser Arafat?

Stephen Hayward, of the American Enterprise Institute, authored a book in 2004 called The Real Jimmy Carter. The book provides a lot of fodder for Hayward's belief that Carter's reputation for post-presidential "statesmanship" is vastly overrated. While I differ with some of Hayward's more vicious pronouncements, I am fast coming to the same conclusion.

I don't think Carter is an evil man, as some conservatives argue. I am a big admirer of all he has done for the Habitat for Humanity; he has really brought their work to a level of awareness that it probably would never have achieved without his assistance in the mid-'80's. The Carter Center in Atlanta also seems to be responsible for a lot of needed humanitarian effort, though I haven't done a lot of homework on what they have accomplished.

Today, though, the world suffers from an overabundance of good people who "know" falsely and act with accompanying arrogance, and Carter qualifies for this description, as well as another label: "useful idiot."

Jimmy Carter was sent packing in 1980 because the American public was weary of his blustering moral certainty accompanied by a lackluster leadership performance across the board. The same man who declared "I'll never lie to you" in 1976 was responsible for one of the most disastrous Presidencies of modern times, rendered stuttering and helpless by the twin factors of inflation and unemployment (stagflation).

He seems to have learned nothing from this electoral whipping in the ensuing 28 years. The term "useful idiot" was applied in the days of Communist predominance by Communist officials toward westerners who were highly regarded in their home countries and were perceived as "good people" but sympathetic toward the Communists. It is too bad that we have to consign an ex-President who has indeed done good things to this category, but that conclusion is becoming more difficult to forestall.

Jimmy, just stay home with Rosalynn and grow peanuts!

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

ive been learning about Jimmy Carter in History lately, and yea, my class doesn't hold him in very hard regard...i didn't think he was all that great a president myself, but you've got to hand it to him, a peanut farmer becoming president? he had to have something going for him.

Glen Asbury said...

Kirsten,

I can see how you could arrive at this conclusion. Indeed, if you study the election of 1976 (which I have to do since, at 1 year old, I was too young to remember it, and I know you weren't going to be born for 15 more years!), you could certainly make the case that Carter had "something going for him."

Carter was elected in a terrible year for Republicans, fresh off the Watergate scandal which culminated in President Richard Nixon's resignation in August 1974. He was a fresh and unknown face to the nation who promised that he would govern ethically and bring results to a nation in gridlock.

He failed spectacularly at the latter. Your parents will remember the gas lines and rampant inflation of the late '70's, as well as the energy crisis in the Middle East, which was taken over by radical Islamists on Carter's watch.

In short, he DID get elected, so we have to credit his shrewdness there. (By the way, yes, he was a peanut farmer, but his farm was a massive collection of farms, rather than just a few acres. Nothing wrong with that, but not quite the small-town image he projected, either.) But, he failed to deliver and was rightly tossed out on his ear in 1980. :)